Hello dear
Welcome to Sonny & Tony's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
At Sonny & Tony's Pizza & Italian Restaurant, located in Mahwah, NJ, passion for authentic Italian cuisine meets a warm, inviting atmosphere. Founded with the intent to serve hearty, flavorful dishes, the establishment has become a beloved local fixture. Guests rave about the crispy crust on their classic cheese pizza and the perfectly executed pasta dishes, like the penne vodka. Accompanied by friendly service and a cozy ambiance, each meal promises to be a delightful experience. Whether you’re seeking a casual dinner or a special gathering, Sonny & Tony’s embodies the essence of Italian dining, making every visit feel like coming home.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
20th Anniversary Bundle
Cheese Steak With Fries Hero
Ham Calzone
Pepperoni Roll
About
Sonny & Tony's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Welcome to Sonny & Tony's Pizza & Italian Restaurant: A Slice of Italy in Mahwah
If you’re in Mahwah, New Jersey, and craving authentic Italian cuisine, look no further than Sonny & Tony's Pizza & Italian Restaurant. Nestled on Ridge Road, this charming eatery offers a delightful combination of traditional flavors and a warm, inviting atmosphere.
Walking into Sonny & Tony's feels like stepping into a cozy Italian home. The friendly staff greets you with a smile, making you feel like part of the family. Whether you desire a casual lunch or a hearty dinner, this restaurant promises to satisfy your cravings.
Menu Highlights: A Feast for the Senses
Sonny & Tony's is renowned for its mouthwatering menu, featuring everything from pizzas to pastas, salads, and delicious rolls. Here are some standouts:
- Pizzas: The classic cheese pizza, as claimed by patrons, is a must-try. With a perfectly crispy crust and flavorful toppings, it is a favorite among many.
- Pasta Dishes: Reviews rave about the penne vodka, which is a creamy delight that embodies the richness of Italian cuisine. Each bite transports you to the heart of Italy.
- Salads: For those looking to balance their meal, the Amalfi Salad, with fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers, is as refreshing as it is beautiful.
- Calzones & Rolls: The Buffalo Chicken Roll and Cheese Calzone have garnered significant praise for their flavor and generous portions, making them perfect for sharing or enjoying solo.
A Satisfying Dining Experience
Customer reviews consistently highlight the freshness and authenticity of the food, speaking to Sonny & Tony's commitment to quality. Kym Martin describes her meal as “fresh, flavorful, and authentically Italian,” praising the attentive service and cozy atmosphere. Another satisfied guest, Aleksandr Andronik, calls it a "cozy and friendly Italian spot," recommending it for casual dinners or takeout.
The experience at Sonny & Tony's goes beyond food; it’s about community. Many returning customers, like Maria Sofia Fossetta, have made this restaurant a lifelong favorite, often highlighting the outstanding service from waitstaff like Oscar and Sean, who enhance the overall dining experience.
Even when dining at home, customers rave about the consistent quality of takeout. Rosemary Brennan shared her delight with the delivery service, where her pizza arrived on time and in perfect condition—something not all restaurants can boast.
Concluding Thoughts
Overall, Sonny & Tony's Pizza & Italian Restaurant is more than just a place to eat; it’s a celebration of Italian culture, wrapped in warmth and flavor. With a menu that caters to all palates and a reputation built on quality and care, this establishment is a must-visit for anyone in the area. Be it a family gathering, a casual meal with friends, or a cozy evening for two, Sonny & Tony’s promises an unforgettable Italian dining experience.
For reservations or takeout, you can reach them at +1 201-529-4001. Experience the joy of authentic Italian cuisine at Sonny & Tony's—you’ll find yourself coming back for more!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Great Italian Dining Experience! I had a fantastic meal at Sonny & Tony's Restaurant . The food was fresh, flavorful, and authentically Italian. The pasta was perfectly cooked and the pizza had a delicious crispy crust. The atmosphere was cozy, and the service was friendly and attentive. I’ll definitely be coming back! ”
“ Really impressed! Calamari was really good. The cappuccino was amazing. And the main meal was really good as well. Definitely recommend it for the quality. ”
“ We Sony & Tony! We have been coming here for so many years, whether for lunch, dinner, or after work. Even now that we are retired, we still enjoy our time at Sony & Tony. Our amazing waiter, Oscar, is the best! We also met a new waiter named Sean, who is just as nice and friendly as Oscar. The food is delicious—yum! ”
“ Love the food here,friendly staffand can bring the family here plus inexpensive. Update just went back here last night food is so good love the pizza.update just had a delivery from here got a personal pizza with extra cheese it arrived on time and it was in perfect condition the cheese didn't slide off the pizza .When I get it at other places always find it is a mess cheese all over the place except the pie.Great job Sonn and Tony's a the delivery man.udate 4 /26/23 Had a delivery made pizza very good but they have to cut the pit better this isn't the first time had this issue trouble pulling apart and finding where one slice ends and one begins. Other than that pizza was delicious. ”
“ Sonny & Tony’s is a cozy and friendly Italian spot in Mahwah with amazing pizza and pasta. Their classic cheese pizza is delicious, and the penne vodka is a must-try. The staff is kind, service is fast, and the atmosphere feels like home. Great place for a casual dinner or takeout. Highly recommended! ”
“ Every time I visit New Jersey, there’s one stop I have to make before heading back home—this amazing pizza spot. It’s hands-down one of my absolute favorite pizza places in the state. No trip back is complete without grabbing a slice (or two)! The pizza itself is perfection—always fresh, with that perfect balance of crispy crust, rich sauce, and gooey, melty cheese. But what makes this place truly special isn’t just the incredible food—it’s the people. The staff is always welcoming, treating everyone like family, which only adds to the charm. Beyond that, this place holds a special place in my heart. It brings back so many memories of my childhood—sharing pies with my family, sitting at the tables with friends, or just stopping in for a quick slice and a drink. It’s the kind of spot that makes you feel at home no matter how much time has passed. If you’re in New Jersey and looking for a pizza place that delivers not just on flavor but on nostalgia and warmth, this is it. Trust me, it’s worth the visit—every single time. ”
“ Amazing food and amazing service. Every time I’m here they are amazing. It’s the best Italian food/ pizzeria in Mahwah. Must try the chicken parm sandwich. ”
“ Friendliest staff that remembers your order! Love being a regular at this restaurant. Any slice of pizza is to die for and my favorite lunch is a chicken cutlet caesar wrap. It stays together, plenty of dressing, parm cheese and oh so amazing chicken cutlet, Id eat it every day. just amazing. I cant wait to explore more options ”